Assalamualaikum VogelTai,
Not to dash your sweet dream guy, but sincerely, pls try to look for more pious Muslim guys out there for prospective future partner.
Sure, you 've downlisted prospective hunks to only revert (newly converted) Muslim Brothers, but do not limit your choices for that particular group. Muslims, especially born Muslims, comes from diverse ethnics background & cultures.
Sometimes, newly reverted Brothers have issues .... in a time where their Iman were not really that strong to resist temptation. If you want to really find a reverted Muslim guy (well, its your cup o' tea), make sure him atleast already possessed basic Islamic knowledge & living the way Islam has prescribed to him. In a way, the minimum requirement would be, he must already know how to pray 5 times a day, fasting in the whole month of Ramadhan etc .... because, a married Muslim man MUST BECOME THE IMAM IN THE FAMILY.
Sincere advise,
Brother in Islam